patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Residents Plan Anti-Charter School Rally For Friday

The rally is opposing the Mandarin-immersion charter school that would draw students from South Orange, Maplewood and West Orange.

 

With the latest application by the Hua Mei in the process, some Maplewood, West Orange and South Orange residents are joining together to fight it.

On Friday, January 6 at 4:30 p.m.,residents will be meeting at the Maplewood Community Center in DeHart Park to protest the application. More than 1,500 residents have already signed a petition that asks Acting Education Commissioner Christopher Cerf to reject Hua Mei’s application, something that has happened before. 

In September, Hua Mei was not one of the charter school applications accepted by the New Jersey Board of Education. The group came back with an amended application that removed Millburn and Livingston as districts to be served. The previous application had met with substantial opposition from the Livingston and Millburn districts

Residents who thought the battle was over were dismayed at the reapplication.

“I couldn’t believe it because it felt like my community was trapped in some kind of bad TV sitcom,” Marian Raab, a Maplewood mother of two young children and one of the organizers of the rally, said in a news release. “The state had just rejected this school’s application earlier this year after the vast majority of local residents came out against it.”

The rally is expected to attract local elected officials as well. The release touted appearances by State Senator Richard Codey, Assemblywoman Mila Jasey and Assemblyman John McKeon. The three legislators are among the sponsors of a bill that would allow either voters or a district’s board of school estimates to vote on charter school applications. The measure has passed the Assembly and is awaiting consideration in the Senate.

“This is a scary example of how the charter school movement has gone off the rails,” Raab continued in the statement. “Right now, local school districts in New Jersey have absolutely NO control over which charter schools can open in their towns, even though those schools would drain significant funding from already cash-strapped and stressed public school budgets. This is terrible public policy that must be changed to give control back to local residents.”

Related Topics: Charter Schools

Allison Kalsched

8:01 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

I wish I could attend this rally. If there are any plans to allow for people who can't make it to be represented, please let me know. I couldn't agree more with Ms. Raab.

Reply
Comment_arrow

jutta Gassner-Snyder

9:13 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

Dear Allison - you can voice your opinion by signing the petition in favor of the Hua Mei Charter School, and please share the petition link and the url for Hua Mei with as many of your friends and family members; thank you in advance

ttp://www.ipetitions.com/petition/hua-mei-charter-school-petition/signatures

www.huameicharterschool.org

Comment_arrow

Marian Raab

9:31 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

Allison,

Thank you for your support. Sorry to hear you can't make our rally in OPPOSITION to the Hua Mei charter school application. You can sign these two online petitions urging Education Commissioner Chris Cerf to once again REJECT Hua Mei's application:

http://www.change.org/petitions/nj-education-commissioner-chris-cerf-reject-the-hua-mei-charter-school-application

http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/somsdcharterconcerns2/

Save Our Schools NJ

8:56 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

Please sign the Save Our Schools NJ petition for local approval of new charter schools, so communities can stop fighting this battle every few months and focus on educating our children! http://www.change.org/petitions/new-jersey-communities-want-local-control-over-new-charter-schools-2

Every signature generates letters to the Senate Education Committee members and to Senate President Sweeney. The bill already passed the NJ Assembly and we are up to 15 Senate supporters, and climbing. Your signatures are critical to helping pass this legislation and to protecting our public schools!

Reply

jutta Gassner-Snyder

9:10 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

Hua Mei Charter School launched their web page; please take a look and sign the petition in favor of Hua Mei for promoting public school choice.

http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/hua-mei-charter-school-petition/http://huameicharterschool.org/support/

Reply

Marian Raab

9:41 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

And for others who can't attend this Friday's rally opposing Hua Mei's application and supporting LOCAL control over the charter school application process, please e-mail Acting Education Commissioner Chris Cerf urging him to once again REJECT this "Boutique" Mandarin immersion charter school.

We CAN make a difference and have a voice in this totally undemocratic process!

Here's Cerf's e-mail address. Your message doesn't have to be long, but be sure to include your full name and the name of the town in which you live. Thanks again for all your support and signatures.

commissioner@doe.state.nj.us

Reply

Allison Kalsched

10:12 pm on Monday, January 2, 2012

Jutta: I am not sure you understood my posting. I am OPPOSED to the school and would like to attend the rally in opposition to the school, but I can't.

And, in M/SO, we do have public school choice. People can opt to go to Seth Boyden if they choose.

To others who responded, thanks. I have signed the petition and will send emails to the Commissioner.

Reply

mark slade

9:31 am on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Public Policy has to be amended when it comes to Charter Schools. If they want to open up a school, that is great; but, allowing them to siphon funding away from the corresponding school budget without voter endorsement is unacceptable.

Reply

Janet Pax

8:22 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

PLEASE, TO all say NO to Charter Schools. we do not need it so say NO.no NO AND
NO.

Reply

Marian Raab

9:55 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Julia Sass Rubin has stated many times in the press and elsewhere that she has a child in a charter school, no big surprise there...Save Our Schools NJ is very clear that they do NOT oppose charter schools--they SUPPORT local choice in the charter school approval process, as do I. Big difference.

Reply

Marian Raab

10:07 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Last but not least, here's Ms. Rubin's bio from a recent op-ed she wrote for NJ Spotlight:

"Julia Sass Rubin is an associate professor at the Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Policy at Rutgers, a mom of a charter school student, and one of the founding members of Save Our Schools NJ, a nonpartisan, grassroots, completely volunteer organization whose members believe that every child in New Jersey should have access to a high quality public school education."

http://www.njspotlight.com/stories/11/1012/1519/

Reply

wohopeful

10:19 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Ms. Raab, it is clear that Ms. Rubin's position is it is ok for her child and family to have access to a free public charter school but not ok for the rest of us. Otherwise why participate in a rally that clearly is to oppose a specific charter school and not the legislation currently in place. If you and Ms. Rubin were rallying in Trenton to get the lawmakers to change the process perhaps it wouldn't be so hypocritical of her. But fact is the rally for Friday is clearly opposing a specific charter and not the legislators in Trenton who have stalled educational reform, so Ms. Rubin can dress her hypocrisy any way she chooses but it doesn't change the fact that she does not want us to have educational choice and opportunity but a ails herself of it freely.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Julia

10:27 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Actually, Wohopeful, I am not participating in Friday's rally. However, Save Our Schools NJ organizers from Maplewood and Millburn will be speaking about the status of the local control legislation and what residents can do to encourage its passage.

You are correct that Save Our Schools NJ does not take positions on individual charter schools because we believe it should be up to the residents of those school districts.

Cynthia Cumming

10:25 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Oh Woho, now you are bothering the good people of Maplewood? For Maplewood readers, "WoHopeful" stole my moniker from NJ.com and started posting vitriolic, vile posts about the West Orange school district, me, the superintendent, the Mayor, the town council, and more on the West Orange Patch. He has stolen other people's monikers, such as Westorangevoice, which he now uses on Nj.com West Orange forum. Additionally, he has posted under other names, such as Joe Arronziola, WOMS, WoMadam, and probably more. That being said, 'WoHo' doesn't give a rat's butt about 'choice'. He only cares about his property taxes and the dissolution of the public school system in New Jersey. He supported William Eames for Senator and spends much of his time maligning Senator Codey as well. That about sums up Woho's M.O. Please pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.

Reply

Cynthia Cumming

10:26 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Oh yea, and SOS-Wo (Save Our Schools West Orange) opposes this Charter School as well.

Reply

wohopeful

10:49 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Ms. Cumming, unfortunately you leave out the part where you are a misguided shill of the WO School Superintendent who spammed the township residents on his behalf with attacks on Board of Education members when his job was supposedly on the line. But let's not digress.

It is important that the residents have all of the facts, and clearly Ms. Rubin participating in a rally that targets one specific charter school when she herself enrolls her daughter in a free public charter school in a posh NJ suburb is hypocritical. She then attempts to veil her hypocrisy by telling us she opposes the current laws, however she is not marching on Trenton she is targeting residents of West Orange, SouthOrange and Maplewood to prevent the same educational opportunities and choice she available herself of. Unfortunately you and Ms. Raab appear to be easily duped by her charade.

Reply

Cynthia Cumming

10:55 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

Contrary to your belief, Mrs. Cumming has a name and a face and stands behind every single word she writes and everything she does. You are a nameless, faceless poster who doesn't even have to courage to post under your own name. As for Ms. Rubin, where she sends her child to school is irrelevant. Her group is not in charge of the rally opposing the charter school. But the parents in West Orange, South Orange and Maplewood will continue to oppose this effort to pull money from our school districts to fund a program that is of no benefit to our children, nor the taxpayers. Oh, and if anyone wants to read about my 'misguided' efforts to support the West Orange Superintendent, please go to: http://westorange.patch.com/articles/superintendent-of-schools-anthony-cavanna-under-review. At that time, Woho was posting under Westorangevoice, another name he stole from someone else.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Brian

2:10 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Cynthia - I really appreciate your insight and opinions on this issue as I have been reading your thoughts and others about the benefits/issues surrounding charter schools and as someone who is relatively new to West Orange who intends to make use of the public schools with my children this insight is really great to hear. I also appreciate you taking the high road to many of these posts as it is refreshing.

Comment_arrow

Cynthia Cumming

3:44 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Brian...thanks. This is about the kids to me. My oldest is a senior at WOHS, my youngest a freshman. They will be fine no matter what happens, but my concern is for the younger ones and how it will affect the school district. And LOL... when I got the notification there was another post, I braced myself!!!

Comment_arrow

wohopeful

8:03 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

"high" being the operative word for Ms. Cumming.

Marian Raab

11:02 pm on Tuesday, January 3, 2012

And I must point out that Woho's personal interpretation of the goals of the rally that I -- along with other community activists in Maplewood, South Orange, West Orange (among other Essex County towns) are organizing -- are factually incorrect. The Jan. 6 rally has ALWAYS been about two things:

1. Letting Acting Commissioner Chris Cerf know that the vast majority of Maplewood, South Orange and West Orange residents OPPOSE the "Boutique" Mandarin-immersion charter school that's now on the DOE's short list for one political official to approve before the decision is actually made; and

2: Supporting LOCAL voter control to the broken New Jersey's charter school law that gives one appointed official in Trenton the power to decide how local school taxpayer-funded money is spent.

But--again--if you don't believe me, here's our description of the rally on a Patch event link:
http://patch.com/E-jW8p

Reply

wohopeful

6:28 am on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

And I continue to point out that your issue is with the legislators in Trenton Ms. Raab and not with the founders of a single charter school which you and Ms. Rubin have chosen to single out and vilify. Why not take your case to Trenton and march on the State Senate who has failed to see the merit of the legislation you seek instead of opposing the educational opportunities and choice for local children and families.

Ms. Rubin's hypocrisy of opposing the Hua Mei Charter school when she herself enrolls her child in a public charter school in a posh NJ suburb is appalling. Why didn't she work to improve her local schools? Why didn't she avail herself of a private school when clearly she has the means to pay for it. She then attempts to veil the apparent hypocrisy by saying she is an proponent of charters but just doesn't like how they are approved. Well again, instead of villifying a single charter school application, go to Trenton and make her case with the legisilators and stop opposing educational choice and opportunites for the children of South Orange, West Orange, and Maplewood.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Julia

7:16 am on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Wehopeful,

It is really unfortunate that you have chosen to try and change the subject rather than dealing with the issue of how charter schools are approved. None of your posts even remotely relate to what others have written previously.

I would ask that you leave my child and my family -- whom you know NOTHING about -- out of your future vitriolic writings. You do not even have the courage to post under your own name when attacking others. How weak and cowardly of you.

Trying to make this about me is an obvious and pathetic attempt to change the conversation. It is also emblematic of how people like yourself have cheapened our public discourse and made it difficult for people to find common ground.

Comment_arrow

wohopeful

5:54 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Ms. Rubin, I have not changed the subject, just read the title line “Residents Plan Anti-Charter School Rally…”

This has always been about a group of misguided individuals trying to vilify the men and women who hope to bring educational improvements in the form of educational choice and opportunities for the children of West Orange, South Orange, and Maplewood. The fact that I pointed out the hypocrisy of someone telling the people of West Orange, South Orange and Maplewood to oppose the Hua Mei Charter school when they themselves avail their child of the educational opportunity and choice of a charter school is simply presenting all of the facts. I find it interesting that you behaved the way you did when the veil was removed from your hypocrisy.

If anyone has cheapened public discourse it would be people like yourself who find that it is ok to have the availability of a public charter school for themselves with no intention of giving it up and want to tell others that they should oppose a charter school in their own district.

If this was truly about legislative change then you should advocate that these misguided folks take their fight to the legislation in Trenton and not vilify the brave men and women who are forging educational reform for our children.

Comment_arrow

Cynthia Cumming

6:10 pm on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

Whoops. Left out the part about Woho being such a misogynist. Perhaps the He Man Woman Haters Club will be out at the rally, along with the I Hate Teachers and Public Schools Compendium.

Marian Raab

7:52 am on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

So funny that Woho mentioned Trenton and lobbying state legislators. Just happens that in addition to helping organize Friday's rally--where Sen. Dick Codey, Assemblywoman Mila Jasey and Assemblyman John McKeon are scheduled to attend--I am also working to get charter reform legislation passed in the state legislature to give LOCAL control over the charter school approval process so communities don't have to fight OVER AND OVER again to let the state Education Commissioner know our views...And again, that's one of the main issues we are hitting at Friday's rally.

But--if you don't believe me--here's an article I wrote for Barista Kids and Baristanet earlier this week about the Hua Mei rally and why it's also about why NJ desperately needs charter school reform legislation:

http://kids.baristanet.com/2012/01/op-ed-join-our-rally-in-opposition-to-hua-mei-charter-school-and-in-support-of-local-control/

Reply

Marian Raab

8:00 am on Wednesday, January 4, 2012

As I wrote in the piece:

"This is why we have scheduled a rally in opposition to Hua Mei and in support of local control over the charter school approval process."

Last but not least, OK, you got me--- I admit that I haven't been to Trenton yet this year (Hey--cut me some slack. it's only Jan. 4) Nevertheless, Woho can rest assured that I'll be in and around the Statehouse this term working to get bi-partisan charter school reform legislation -- that was overwhelmingly passed by the New Jersey Assembly last year-- passed and signed into law in 2012.

Reply

A

11:20 am on Friday, January 6, 2012

Go Marian!!!! 100% behind you.

Reply

Susan1

2:52 pm on Friday, January 6, 2012

Thanks for your hard work, Marian. I emailed Commissioner Cerf this week, and I hope others will as well. We need to also keep the pressure on our elected officials, however. Even if Hua Mei is denied this round, they will certainly be back. Legislative reform is our only hope. Good luck!!

Reply

Leave a comment